- Compare plan fees with your full fees for the procedures you do most, weighted by volume.
- Calculate what share of those patients you'd need to keep at full fee to break even if you left.
- Renegotiation is often a better first step than leaving.
How PPO fees work
Every PPO plan has a fee schedule: a list of what it pays for each procedure code. When you're in-network, you agree to accept that fee as payment in full, even if your normal fee is higher. The difference is a write-off.
Step 1: List your most common procedures
Pull a report of the procedures you perform most often for patients on this plan. For most general practices, the top 20 codes make up the large majority of production. You don't need every code; the common ones tell the story.
Step 2: Compare fees, weighted by volume
For each code, multiply both your full fee and the plan's fee by how many times you performed it last year. Weighting matters: a big discount on a rare procedure matters less than a small discount on cleanings you do every day.
| Procedure (example) | Your fee | Plan fee | Times / year | Full-fee total | Plan total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| D0120 Periodic exam | $65 | $42 | 1,200 | $78,000 | $50,400 |
| D1110 Adult cleaning | $120 | $78 | 1,100 | $132,000 | $85,800 |
| D0274 Four bitewing X-rays | $85 | $55 | 900 | $76,500 | $49,500 |
| D2392 Two-surface filling | $260 | $165 | 300 | $78,000 | $49,500 |
| Total | $364,500 | $235,200 |
Step 3: The break-even question
If you left this plan, some patients would stay and pay your full fee (or use out-of-network benefits) and some would leave. To earn the same revenue, you'd need to keep $235,200 ÷ $364,500 = 64.5% of that work at full fee.
If you believe you'd keep more than about two-thirds of those patients, leaving could make sense. If you'd keep fewer, staying in or renegotiating is safer. Leaving also frees chair time, which you could fill with higher-paying patients, so factor in how full your schedule is.
Your options
- Stay in-network and focus on efficiency, if the plan brings steady volume and your schedule has open time.
- Renegotiate. Many plans will review fees, especially for practices with strong reviews or in underserved areas. Bring your numbers.
- Leave gradually. Drop the lowest-paying plan first and track how many patients stay.
- Offer an in-house membership plan for uninsured or out-of-network patients.
PPO contracts have notice periods and terms. Review your contract (and get advice if needed) before making changes.
This guide is general educational information, not tax, legal or financial advice for your specific situation.