GuideMedical · Dental7 min read

Provider compensation models compared

How you pay doctors, dentists, nurse practitioners and associates is one of the biggest financial decisions a practice makes. This guide explains the four common models in plain language, with the trade-offs of each.

The short version
  • Salary is predictable but doesn't reward productivity.
  • Productivity and collections models reward output but shift risk to the provider.
  • Base-plus-bonus blends both and is the most common middle ground.

Why the model matters

A compensation model is a set of incentives. Pay people a flat salary and they're rewarded for showing up. Pay them a share of what they bring in and they're rewarded for seeing more patients. Neither is wrong, but each one changes behavior and changes how much risk the practice carries.

1. Straight salary

The provider gets a fixed annual amount, no matter how many patients they see.

  • Good for: new providers building a patient base, and practices that value teamwork over volume.
  • Watch out for: the practice carries all the risk. If the provider is slow, you still pay full salary.

2. Productivity (wRVU-based)

Medicare assigns every medical service a number called a work RVU (relative value unit) that reflects how much effort it takes. A practice can pay a set dollar amount per wRVU. More work means more pay, regardless of which insurance the patient has.

Worked example
Productivity pay
wRVUs produced in a year5,000
Rate per wRVU$50
Annual compensation$250,000
  • Good for: rewarding effort fairly across payers.
  • Watch out for: the practice still carries collection risk. A provider can produce wRVUs on claims that are never paid.

3. Percentage of collections

The provider receives a percentage of the money actually collected from their work. This is very common for dental associates, often in the high-20s to mid-30s percent range depending on market and who pays for supplies and lab.

Worked example
Collections-based pay
Collections from the provider's work$700,000
Provider percentage35%
Annual compensation$245,000
  • Good for: the practice, because you only pay when you get paid.
  • Watch out for: providers may avoid low-paying patients or procedures, and income can swing month to month.

4. Base salary plus bonus

A guaranteed base salary, plus a bonus once the provider passes a target. It's the most common compromise.

Worked example
Base plus bonus
Base salary$200,000
Bonus: 20% of collections above $650,000
Provider collects $750,000, so bonus = 20% × $100,000$20,000
Annual compensation$220,000

Side by side

ModelIncome stabilityRewards outputPractice risk
Straight salaryHighLowHigh
Productivity (wRVU)MediumHighMedium
% of collectionsLowHighLow
Base + bonusMedium-highMediumMedium

Before you sign an offer, model it

  • How long will this provider take to reach a full schedule?
  • What will they cost per month while they ramp up, including benefits and payroll taxes?
  • What happens to your cash flow if they take twice as long as expected?
  • Does the model encourage the behavior you actually want?

Compensation agreements are legal contracts and, in healthcare, have to follow federal rules on referrals. Have a healthcare attorney review any agreement before you sign.

Free tool
New hire break-even calculator
Estimate how long a new provider takes to pay for themselves.
Try it

This guide is general educational information, not tax, legal or financial advice for your specific situation.

← Previous guide
13-week cash forecast template for practices
Next guide →
Opening a practice: the financial launch checklist
Get Started Today

Want these numbers for your practice, every month?

We track all of this for you and explain what it means in plain English. Start with a free 30-minute consultation.

Schedule a Free Consultation